How Do You Know If Your Business Idea is a Good One?

TQ-Day 01_219

Before we begin, let me give it to you straight. Starting your own business is bloody hard. So hard in fact that most of you reading this will quit before you’ve really began. A slightly harsh way to start an article about success you might think, but that’s really the whole point. Remember, if it was easily attainable, everyone would be accomplishing it. If I told you it was going to be an easy ride, I’d be doing you much more of a disservice.

Running a successful business is not easy. Working for someone else is easy. Letting someone else make all the difficult decisions is easy. Working an eight hour day and taking home a regular pay check is easy. Running your own business is as far from easy as it can possibly get.

When you decide to strike out on your own you will be inundated with people ‘helpfully’ offering you their advice and opinions. They’ll tell you that you’re mad to want to quit your job, and that leaving behind the security of a regular income is crazy… and in many ways they are completely right.

If I’ve kept you this far then hopefully you’re now thinking “Screw that! I’d rather work twice as hard so I can live a life and create something I really want – whatever the cost” and if that’s the case, then congratulations my friend, you may just have a shot.

Yet passion and determination are only one piece of the pie. You first have to have a damn good idea and then the drive, ambition and forward planning to actually make it happen.

TQ-Day 01_187

The Idea

For some people, coming up with their business idea is easy. They have a lightbulb moment or a brainwave when they least expect it. But for the rest of us it can take years to uncover exactly what it is we really want to do. So just how do you know if your latest business idea is a ‘good’ one or not?

Of course no-one can give you a definitive answer to this biggest of questions but there are a few things you can do when trying to figure this out for yourself. Firstly you need to obsessively research your chosen field and profession. You need to devour books, blogs, workshops and training courses. You need to take in as much information as possible and then you need to work your butt off practising over and over and over again.

If this sounds like a lot of work then you may not have uncovered your brilliant business idea just yet. However if this is something you’ve already done or you can’t wait to get stuck into then you might just be on the right path.

If you’re not obsessed with your chosen idea then drop it and move on. You have to really love what you do, and be willing to do it for free (or at least very little money) for a significant amount of time before you really make any traction or even a sniff of profit. If you’re not willing to work for free then you’ll likely give up before you’ve even really got started. If you don’t completely love what you plan to do then working for a regular pay check is always going to be an easier route to take.

TQ-Day 01_222

Working for free gets a bad rep, but getting some experience under your belt before you start worrying about charging for what you do will be hugely beneficial for you and your potential customers. If you’re an aspiring photographer try to second shoot a wedding; if you want to be a blogger then work on your writing, figure out your niche and build up your readership and industry connections before you try to monetise; if you want to design stationery ask a friend who’s getting married if you can create theirs as a wedding gift.

Working for free enables you to not only get some first-hand experience in the area you want to go into, but gives you the opportunity to then ask for some honest and valuable feedback. Feedback can sometimes be tough to take (because, let’s be honest, who gets it all right first time?!) but it’s vital if you want to improve and grow. Ask people how they found working with you but also what they’d really love from someone doing what you offer. While you should always stick to your own core values, sometimes other people will notice a few little things that you didn’t realise needed improving. We grew the experience of The Blogcademy exponentially after getting some constructive feedback from our students in those first few classes.

If I’ve learnt anything from launching and running two successful businesses in the past five years, it is that looking for gaps in the market is imperative. There are a million other bloggers, photographers, designers and teachers out there, and so the best way to make sure you rise to the top is to differentiate yourself.

TQ-Day 01_188

Look to your core values and ask yourself “what is it that makes me different?” The answer to that question is likely to be the ultimate key to finding your right path. In an over-saturated market like the wedding industry, clients are much more prone to book the suppliers that they click with.

If an engaged couple were looking at two wedding photographers, for example, and they both offered similar styles of work, packages and prices, what is it that will make them pick one over the other? The likelihood is that they’ll choose the one that they get on best with or who shares similar interests to them. So instead of taking the safe path and trying to be the same as everyone else, embrace what makes you weird/ awesome/ unique and run with it. Remember, if you try to appeal to everyone, you’ll end up appealing to no-one.

The Plan

Once you’ve come up with your grand idea, the next thing you need to do is to construct a business plan. This is crucial for moving your business in the right direction. Full disclosure: I did not do this (I started Rock n Roll Bride as a hobby and it actually became my business completely by accident). However I know that if I had done, I would have been able to make my blog profitable a lot sooner than I did.

The benefit of a business plan is firstly that you have concrete goals to work towards, but also that you’re not just ambling along without any direction. Knowing where you want to get to and working out exactly what you need to do in order to get there will help you move along a lot quicker and make much more strategic decisions.

Year one will be tough and you’ll likely not make much money. You’ll be working ridiculously long hours building your client base, working on your brand and honing your skills. The easy option will still be to go back to working for someone else. However if you have a long term plan of where you want to go and how you’re going to make it happen then you’re much less likely to quit.

TQ-Day 01_192

The misconception amongst a lot of new business owners (especially online) is that everyone else has it so much easier than they do. Everyone else appears to have it all figured out and to have found success quickly and easily. This is not the case at all. In this age of social media we’ve all got very adept at only sharing our carefully editing highlights online. The internet has made us all impatient for success but a business plan will keep you grounded and encourage you to look forwards and not sideways at what everybody else is doing.

The Action

After coming up with your idea, obsessing over it, researching it like a crazed fan and plotting out how you’re going to make it happen comes the final, most as crucial part: the action. Ideas are pointless without it.

You need to keep practicing, keep learning and to be open to making a few mistakes along the way. You need to realise that there is a chance you could fail but that you’re going to keep plodding on anyway.

In moments of uncertainly, always remember that no-one else has lived your life or has your experiences and that differentiating yourself is what will ultimately allow you to stand out. Always refer back to that business plan and remember to occasionally stop and notice just how far you’ve come.

Each and every turn in this journey you’re about to take will be an amazing opportunity for growth and improvement. Even if your first idea doesn’t take off in the way you might have hoped, revel in the fact that it’s still taught you something that you can keep using when you come up with your next one. Then go back and start again.

Instant success is rare and it not reaching it right away certainly doesn’t mean that you’ve failed. I firmly believe that no idea is a failure; it’s simply a work in progress.



  1. Hello,

    I just wanted to say that even though I am single and no where near getting married yet, I somehow stumbled across your blog and find it a massive source of inspiration and encouragement.

    I quit uni to start a business selling vintage clothes, I am still very much in the planning stages and trying to work out how I can make my business unique – there are a LOT of vintage clothes sellers out there! But reading an article like this just makes my passion grow stronger. I could not bear to think of working to next 40 years for someone else.

    So thank you for the inspiration and all the beautiful pictures!


  2. Danielle

    Great read! I follow you for wedding stuff but I think I like the business posts more. Hope to see you guys at the Blogcademy next year in NZ 🙂

  3. This article couldn’t come at a better time! I quit my job 2 months ago to run my design business and blog full time. Yesterday I was told about a really well paid opportunity to take a 6 month design contract with a large Australian company. No idea what to do! I don’t want to give up on my fledgling business in this crucial stage, but it seems like too good of an opportunity to pass up.

  4. Libby

    I cannot say thank you enough for this inspiring read!! I am currently working through the business plan process in hopes of (scary!) securing financing. Your article really reminded me to keep forefront in my mind the reasons I am starting my business in the first place. Some great motivation during a needed time, thanks Kat!

  5. Post author

    Lisa – I actually just wrote an article about the benefits of having a full time job while starting your own business! It will be up on Tuesday next week. Hope it can help

  6. Helen Burgin

    I love this!

    I’ve been running my own little corner of the art world for some time and am in the process of starting up a new business completely detached from my comfort zone but essentially to support my hubby. It is awesome to remind yourself of such things.

    I think this time round, the passion comes from wanting to support him, believing in his amazing idea and showing him that it really is worth chasing your dream if you believe in it! It’s a challenge but I’m enjoying learning a helluva lot!

    Thank you again RnRB!!

  7. 100% spot on Kat. It’s harder than anyone working a 9-5 can imagine, and i’ve spent the last year doing both. It’s nice to read all of the things I also believe make a business succeed.
    Nothing of any worth will ever come easily.
    Great post.

  8. Sara

    Hey there, Kat. I agree with everything you wrote. That said, doesn’t everyone wish that their brilliant notebook of ideas would suddenly spawn a million dollars? Some people couldn’t quit their 9-5 because they’re still gearing to save up for that business and the predicted idle time. Like me, for example. I wish I could just take that big leap. Great, great article you got here.

  9. Debi

    Hi Kat!
    Love this article – I am just in the process of starting my own cake business (don’t worry I have read your more recent blog about not quitting the day job!!) along side my main job.

    It is just so difficult to know where to start, as on one side you have friends and family telling you how talented you are and on the you have so many other people already there and making it look easy but you just dont know all the information.

    I love reading your blog and plan to make my own wedding cake at least, when it eventually happens 😉 I find the information in your green room section of your blog so interesting and useful, I will keep going!

    Debi 🙂


Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *